 THE AMERICAN UNIVERSITY  IN CAIRO
Engineering Department
General Electrical Engineering

Application Project
Power Factor Improvement
Based on a study done for an industrial plant
Presented to:
Dr. Mahmoud Gilany

Presented by:

I-Abstract:

The aim of this technical report is to introduce a summary for a study done by a public sector company for power factor improvement. This report includes an electrical engineering background about the problem of power factor, including: the causes, the consequences, the economical importance for the company and for the country as well, and  the theoretical solution for solving that problem.
The report links the theoretical solution with the real applicable solution through the study done by the organization for energy planning. This study includes a nine months research done by the researchers and the electrical engineers, that represents an ideal methodology for solving this problem starting from defining the magnitude of the power factor problem until designing the equipment that can solve that problem.
The report represents all the previous points in simple terminology, according to the objectives of the course ENGR 318 (general electrical engineering).

Topic Page
Introduction 3
Objectives 5
Theory 5
Description of Experiments and Apparatus 6
Procedure (work plan) 7
Results 9
Discussion 10
Recommendations 10
References 10

III-Nomenclature:

Symbol Meaning  Unit
S Apparent (total) Power  kVA (VA = Volt Ampere)
P Active (real) power kWatt
Q Reactive power  kVAR
Vline Line Voltage kVolt
Vphase Phase Voltage kVolt
Iphase Phase Current  A (A= Amperes)
cos f Power Factor  determines the amount utilized of S
f Phase Angle angle between the current and the voltage Radians
Xc Capacitive reactance Ohms
Vrated Rated voltage for a device kVolt

IV-Introduction:

Industrial plants usually pay large fines because of any large inductive loads in their factories. Inductive loads result from the storage of energy in magnetic fields, which occurs in coils of wire, such as in motor windings and transformers. To decrease high electricity bills resulting from these large inductive loads, capacitors may be installed at the facility to increase the power factor.
Power factor is the ratio of active (real) power to apparent (total) power. (1)  P.F.=cos  F=P/S
Apparent power is made up of two components, called active power and reactive power. Reactive power, whether inductive or Capacitive, always acts at right angles to active power. Reactive power is not useful in an industrial setting, as it does no real work when supplied to motors or other electrical devices. Power distribution company in Egypt bill customers for how much reactive power they use, and since reactive power supplies no benefit to the manufacturer, it is desirable to reduce or eliminate the reactive component of power that the manufacturer uses.
For any three phase factory, the amount of the active power required from the source to run its machines is: (2)
Assuming that the amount of apparent power supplied to the factory constant, and that the load consumption of reactive power becomes less, then the current becomes smaller. Hence, voltage drop, power, and energy losses decrease. This enables the factory to add more loads using the same power stations.
The problem with low power factor exceeds the commonly known consequences, such as: power, energy, and voltage losses. Along with these consequences, the active power produced will decrease. This mainly affects power stations, either the main stations or sub-stations installed in the plant. They have to work faster, and large amounts of fuel will be consumed to make up for the reactive losses.
Since the current is inversely proportional to the power factor, it can be proved that power losses are inversely proportional to the square of the power factor.
P loss = I^2 R    (3)
Thus power factor improvement is a method to reduce network losses, either active power of reactive power.
Both Power consumers and suppliers are interested in power factor improvement. For consumers, they have to decrease the economical losses because of the high fine assigned by the power supplier because of the low power factor. In Egypt, some companies pay large fines because of the low power factors in case the power factor is below 0.9 along with the power bill due to the normal consumption. For the suppliers, the request for power will decrease resulting in a decrease in the amount of fuel used in the power stations.
It is known that the power factor for a fully loaded induction motor ranges between 0.75 to 0.85. When the motor load is below rated, the power factor drops since the motor draws less active power and about the same reactive power.
In conclusion, low power factor results in:
1- Large power losses in the lines, transformers and generators.
2- Extra copper and aluminum good conductors have to be used to minimize
losses.
3- Smaller capacities of transformers and lines must be used to avoid power losses due to the large current flowing out.
4- Lower network voltage due to the large current.

There are some factors that motivate the companies to improve their power factors, these are:
1 -  The economical importance (elimination of the power factor penalty):

Some factories pay large fines because of their low power factor, sometimes larger than the normal power consumption bill. In Egypt, the power distribution companies give bonuses for the companies of high P.F. (more than 0.9)

2 -  Reduction of internal power losses:

These losses may take the shape of reactive power, or power, energy, and voltage losses.

3 -  Payback period:

After installing the equipment needed to correct the power factor, there will be a very short payback period. This means that the cost of the equipment needed to improve the power factor will be recovered in a very short period. On the other sides, the costs of the equipment are by far less than the fine required from the company due its low P.F. Based on the study, the payback period is 6 months.

V-Objectives:

The aim of this report is to introduce an ideal methodology for power factor improvement of an industrial plant.
The shape of the study was as follows:
1-Introduction:
a -  Description of the low power factor problem.
b -  Description of the industrial plant, and its activities.
c -  Power consumption data.
2-Work plan:
Phase A includes:
a -  Measurements.
b -  Data analysis.
c -  Recommendations.
d -  Equipment design, sizing, and location.
Phase B includes:
a -  Detailed design.
b -  Installation.
c -  Evaluation and supervision.

VI-Theory:

A simple idea for the power factor improvement is the use of a capacitor in parallel to the factory to decrease the reactive power losses.
It is known that in the capacitor the current leads the voltage by a 90° angle. Given that the active and reactive powers are given as: (4,5)
Therefore, for the capacitor P = 0, while Q = -S (because it is the current that leads the voltage).
The meaning of the negative reactive power is that the capacitor can be used as a source of negative reactive power.(i.e., it reduces the reactive power) (6)  For the capacitor, (7)
equating (1) and (2) together gives the value of the capacitance of the capacitor to be installed in parallel to the factory. (8)

VII-Description of the used devices:

Conducting such a study requires collecting of essential data, because dependence on the bills of the distribution company might lead to false design.
The used device is called:
BMI 3030 A Power Profiler
(Energy and harmonic analyzer)
This device is a basic measuring device that measures:
·  True RMS of voltage and current.
·  Active power (kW)
·  Reactive power (kVAR)
·  Apparent power (kVA)
·  True power factor (PF)
·  Harmonic content of the current and voltage
The device records the data on 3.5² floppy disks.

VIII-Procedures (work plan):

PHASE A
1-Measurements:
refer to the section of the used devices

2-Data analysis:

The data retrieved from the measuring device calculates the above mentioned quantities. By analyzing these data, some important facts are highlighted, such as:
·  The power factor calculated by the distribution company was less than the actual power factor. This means that the distribution company measuring devices are not working efficiently and they need to be replaced.
·  Some parts of the plan have high P.F. because they are pure resistive loads.
·  Some motors and transformers are partially loaded.

3-Recommendations:

The P.F. problem can be improved basically without the need to install any capacitors by reducing the amount of reactive power consumed in motors and transformers. This may be achieved by:
·  Installing motors of proper rating, speed, type and size according to the load and the operating of the machine.
·  Replacing large induction motors with synchronous motors.
·  Replacing lightly loaded motors or transformers with others of smaller ratings.
·  Cutting down no load operations of motors through limiters and electrical interlock that disconnect the motor when the operation is terminated. For slightly loaded motors, the electric interlocks might be used to shift the windings from delta to star.(In star Vline =Ö3 Vphase)

These points can be explained as follows. The voltage of the motor determines the self-induced e.m.f  of the motor windings. Thus, the higher the voltage and the lower the load on the motor, the higher the induced e.m.f. and the lower the P.F.
The second problem is the transformers; transformers consume about 30% of the reactive power of the system. Transformers carrying less than 30% of their rating cause enormous losses in the P.F. Thus they should be loaded within a limit of 30è 70%  of their ratings.
Mostly the power factor improvement equipment is capacitors. Their advantage is that they have very small active power losses (0.0025è0.005kW per kVAR). They are simple and easy devices and they do not have rotating parts that may produce inductive reactance.  Their shortcomings are their relatively small life (8à10 years), the potential danger of short-circuit (wiring) of the capacitor in case the voltage exceeds their rated voltage by 1.1Vrated, and that they are unrepairable.

4-Equipment design, sizing and location:

The design of the capacitors depends on the P.F. as above mentioned in the theory section. The difficulty usually lies in the locating the capacitors.
For any plant, the overall average P.F. is different from the P.F. for every sub-station or even each load section of the factory. Thus there is a very important factor that should be considered, which is:

The position of the installed capacitor:

1-Input side of the main power feeder switch gear: This method is less costly for the user than the capacitor used for low voltages. However, it does not eliminate the problem; in a way it increases the overall power factor of the whole plant, but all the inductive reactive currents are still circulating between the factory loads, sub-stations, and the capacitors. Despite improving the power factor, power losses are not reduced to a satisfactory range. Moreover, the cost of switch gears is much expensive when the capacitor is connected to the main power feeder.
2-Input side of each load center: This method is usually used with the third one. The capacitor is installed at the input side of each load center. The total capacitance is divided on all the load centers. Regardless of the fact that the inductive reactive currents will still be flowing between the machines, load center, and the capacitor but they will never reach the main power feeder.
3-Low voltage side of each load center: This method is efficient in both eliminating the low P.F., because the inductive reactive current will be flowing between the motor and the capacitor. However, the price of the capacitors in this case is relatively high because of its small capacitance, thus increasing the payback period.
PHASE B

1-Detailed design:
2-Installation:
It is not intended to go through the technical details of the design and installation, however some points must be mentioned that suit the objectives of the course.
The equipment needed for the P.F. improvement is:
·  Switchboard panel of enameled steel (enclosure IP 30) .
·  Three phase Circuit breakers (air type).
·  Copper bus bars.
·  Capacitors according to the value required (capacitance is measured here in kVAR).
·   Power factor meter and controller.
·  VAR meters

3-Evaluation and supervision:

The capacitors should have the following specifications:
·  There is a need for substitute capacitors to be used in case of maintenance.
·  Each unit should contain discharge resistors to bleed off residual voltages after the disconnection of the power. The discharge time should be around 5 minutes.
·  Vrated should be 1.1 Vrequired-
·  Capacitance variation with temperature should be minimized, either by cooling the capacitor or selecting a capacitor of good temperature-capacitance properties.
·  They should be adapted to automatic step systems controlled by the power factor meters.
·  IP 45

IX-Results:

Quality Before P.F. improvement After P.F. improvement
Average annual P.F. 0.77 0.95
Active power  (P) 2280 kW 2280 kW
Apparent power (S) 3800 kVA 2400 kVA
Annual consumption 5274 MWh 5116 MWh

X-Discussion:

Since the reactive power in factories is due to inductive loads, then they might be compensated by Capacitive reactive loads because they cancel each other. Thus the solution to decrease the inductive reactive power is to increase the Capacitive power because they cancel each other, and hence decreasing the overall reactive power, which is considered as a kind of losses of the total supplied power.

XI-Recommendations:

The problem of power factor is not a smoldering problem that arises all of a sudden. Undoubtedly, this problem is a result of poor electrical engineering design. The problem might be avoided from the start by considering the following facts:
1-Once the motor is loaded less than its rating, the used active power is less. Thus the reactive power takes a large share of the apparent power. Therefore, motors of adequate rate, speed, type, and size should be installed according to the
load and the operating of the machine.
2- As previously mentioned, transformers consume about 30% of the reactive power of the system. Transformers carrying less than 30% of their rating cause enormous losses in the P.F. Thus they should be loaded within a limit of 30è 70%  of their ratings.

XII-References:

Abdel-Aziz, Abdel-Aziz M. Power Factor Improvement  Project. Organization for Energy Planning, Cairo. 1993

Lipkin, B.Y. Electrical Equipment for Industry. Higher School Publishing House, Moscow. 1967.

Directory
Home